November 22, 2024 The Best Source of News, Culture, Lifestyle for Culver City, Mar Vista, Del Rey, Palms and West Los Angeles

SMa.r.t.-Big Versus Small

By Mario Fonda-Bonardi

The story of the small taking down the big is an old one we are all familiar with: think David and Goliath. The modern version might by the low-paid, long-hour worker of China taking down the U.S. industrial behemoth. In that case, the U.S. consumer benefits with low prices but the American manufacturing workers lose their jobs while the Chinese entrepreneur makes millions and the Chinese environment is completely polluted. These kinds of trade-offs are happening all the time, everywhere, including here in Santa Monica.

Take Airbnb for example. This service allows anyone to repurpose an unused extra bedroom, guest house or even basement into a hotel room; thus anyone willing to vacuum and change sheets can become a hotel owner (admittedly it’s a small hotel but it’s a hotel nonetheless). This effectively distributes the tourist/visitor load throughout the City instead of concentrating it along the beach or the boulevards. The main beneficiary is the lower-priced visitor who can now stay in Santa Monica for less than they would otherwise pay, while the owner makes some extra cash. The victims are the neighbors who may be adversely affected by a poorly run Airbnb. Airbnb, while less predictable than an established hotel or hotel chain, eventually might collide with the growth of the established hotel industry by undercutting either their prices or their rate of growth or both. If they are serving two different market segments, there may not be a collision but it’s too early to tell: vacancy rates in Santa Monica during this economic boom time have been rather low.

Analogously there is a relatively new California ordinance that allows an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) to be built in any lot that currently only has one residence on it. This encourages anyone with some extra cash and space to become a developer. The law allows a property owner to add an additional unit, up to 1,200 square feet, in their back yard. This can be done by converting the garage to a habitable space or by carving one out of the existing residence. The important thing is that a replacement garage does not have to be provided nor do you have to provide parking for that new unit. The proliferation of ADUs provides renters in Santa Monica more choices, often in nicer neighborhoods, than the new apartment buildings now being built along the boulevards or downtown do.

Homeowner/developers of the ADUs have the ability to capture some of the ultra-high rents being charged by the competing apartment-rental industry and they can build them faster and cheaper than their would-be competitors.

Like Airbnb there may be adverse effects on surrounding neighbors, particularly on streets already maxed out for parking. Given the demand for housing on the west side by wealthy tenants, ADUs will not liely lower rental prices, but their construction will provide a steady stream of dwellings over time and while not directly taming overdevelopment pressures, may help stabilize the housing market.

In another sector, anyone with a roof can become a power-plant operator by putting solar collectors on it.

Finally another big vs small example is ride sharing services like Lyft or Uber, which have taken down the taxi industry. Again anyone with extra time and a relatively unused clean car can become a driver, undercutting the livelihood of existing services and companies. This also causes collateral damage to our public transit system as people like the convenience, privacy and flexibility of an Uber ride compared to sharing the crowds on a bus and its often irregular schedule.

Naturally, half-empty buses take up as much road-space as full ones so we are not seeing a drop in street traffic and it has actually increased as the boom economy allows more people to buy and drive cars. It’s unclear if the ride-share business model is sustainable, as it creates a race to the bottom for drivers while waiting for the larger taxi companies to fold.

At that point Uber, in certain markets, will be able to exert monopoly pressure as current taxi companies do, but possibly with higher prices. Uber drivers may also lose their jobs entirely with the advent of the self-driving car so the long game is still very much in flux.

There is probably a similar process now at work as the new ubiquitous Bird scooters compete and may undercut the City’s Breeze bikes. It may be that those two services, essential to our city’s mobility, serve different market segments so there is no real conflict; scooters mainly serve locals while many Breeze bikes are used by tourists. Again it’s too early to tell how this will play out, but needless to say the role of helmets or rather their lack may eventually determine the perceived safety of these two modes of transportation.

All of these sharing-economy practices unfolding in our city are very democratic: anyone can be a hotelier, a developer, power-plant operator, or a taxi driver. They upset the current established industries to differing degrees by undercutting the competition and have long term implications including collateral damage for our City’s coffers.

Now if someone could only figure out a way to make everyone a college professor (to deal with the high cost of education) or to make everyone a doctor or drug manufacturer (to deal with the high cost health services) we would reach some sort of Jeffersonian Nirvana!

Accessory Dwelling Units (ADUs) in residents’ backyards are altering the local rental market.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow: Thane Roberts AIA, Robert H. Taylor AIA, Daniel Jansenson Architect, Building and Fire Life-Safety Commissioner, Ron Goldman FAIA, Samuel Tolkin Architect, Mario Fonda-Bonardi AIA, Planning Commissioner, Phil Brock, Arts Commissioner.

Related Posts

Video Shows Officer-Involved Shooting Outside SMPD Station

November 22, 2024

November 22, 2024

Officials Have Issued a Viewer Advisory, Cautioning That the Material May Be Distressing The Santa Monica Police Department has released...

Donate Blood and Save Lives at Culver City Fire Station This Weekend

November 22, 2024

November 22, 2024

Get a T-Shirt, Gift Card for Participating in the Cedars-Sinai Blood Drive The Culver City Rotary Club, in collaboration with...

LAPD Motorcycle Officer Hospitalized After 405 Freeway Crash in Sepulveda Pass

November 21, 2024

November 21, 2024

Collision Near Skirball Center DrivePossibly Involving a Tesla Caused Major Traffic  The 405 Freeway was the scene of a motorcycle...

Santa Monica Police Release Body Cam Footage of Deadly Force Incident Outside Headquarters

November 21, 2024

November 21, 2024

Graphic Video Shows a Violent Assault on an SMPD Officer by a Knife-Wielding Suspect The Santa Monica Police Department (SMPD)...

Breakaway Café Opens New Venice Location with Beachside Grab-and-Go Window

November 20, 2024

November 20, 2024

Bayse Brothers Bring Their Signature Breakfast Dishes and Good Vibes to Venice Breakaway Café, a popular breakfast and lunch eatery...

Last Minute Additions to the Best Thanksgiving 2024 Feasts and Pies To Go

November 20, 2024

November 20, 2024

If Other Faves are Sold Out, Here’s All The Quality Places to Try Now Celebrity chefs Susan Feniger and Mary...

Everytable’s Holiday Meal Collaboration To Support LA’s Unhoused Youth

November 20, 2024

November 20, 2024

Chef Created Thanksgiving Meal Benefits My Friend’s Place. Everytable, the mission-driven company committed to making scratch-cooked, nutritious meals accessible to...

Los Angeles City Council Codifies Sanctuary Protections for Migrants with New Citywide Ordinance

November 19, 2024

November 19, 2024

Mayor Bass Prioritized the Ordinance after Trump’s Mass Deportation Threats The Los Angeles City Council voted unanimously Tuesday to officially...

The Palms Community Council’s Executive Committee Schedules Special Meeting for Nov. 20

November 19, 2024

November 19, 2024

Meeting to Address Open Board Positions and Committee Updates The Executive Committee will hold a special meeting on Wednesday, Nov....

Hammer Museum Presents 10th Edition of MoMA Contenders: Screenings, Conversations with Top Filmmakers

November 19, 2024

November 19, 2024

Lineup Features Films by Steve McQueen, Sean Baker, and Brady Corbett The Hammer Museum will host the 10th edition of...

Film Review: Wicked

November 19, 2024

November 19, 2024

By Dolores Quintana Director John Chu (Crazy Rich Asians, In The Heights) has crafted an effervescent take on the blockbuster...

Randy’s Donuts Arrives in Culver City with Free Donuts and a $250 Gift Card Giveaway

November 19, 2024

November 19, 2024

Grand Opening on November 19 Includes Sweet Giveaways Starting at 6:00 a.m. The time is finally here. Randy’s Donuts is...

Nicole Nagel’s Futuristic Eric Moss Designed Brentwood Home To Hit Auction Block

November 18, 2024

November 18, 2024

The Spaceship-Like Property Heads to Auction With No Reserve in December German actress Nicole Nagel, who was part of the...

LA Controller Kenneth Meija: City Left $513 Million of Homelessness Budget Unspent

November 18, 2024

November 18, 2024

Inefficiencies Blamed for Underspending Despite Record Allocation in FY2024  The City of Los Angeles hasn’t spent over half of its...

West LA College Expands Zero-Cost Textbook Programs with $600K Grant

November 18, 2024

November 18, 2024

College Aims for 50 Zero-Cost Textbook Programs by 2025  West Los Angeles College (West) is expanding its zero-cost textbook program...