April 24, 2025 The Best Source of News, Culture, Lifestyle for Culver City, Mar Vista, Del Rey, Palms and West Los Angeles

SMa.r.t.-Population Overload: Part 2

In this second article SM.a.r.t. (Santa Monica architects for a responsible tomorrow) continues discussing the thorny issue of the optimum Santa Monica population.

 

Before deciding an optimum population for our city, which is the second most denses California coastal city, we should take in a larger context. Most people would agree that space ship earth has too many people today and the aspirations of those billions for a humane life can only be met (and barely) if we reduce the world’s growth rate. Likewise lifeboat Santa Monica can only take on so many passengers before it capsizes. We may disagree on where that “tipping” point is but it is not unlimited as developers would have us believe.

In addition most people understand that we are all engaged in a generation-long migration northward as global warming fries people out of the center of the planet. Trump’s wall will not stop this century-old migration. So is Santa Monica, in a global sense, a city whose population should increase to absorb the climate refugees? Is it city whose population stabilizes as “southern arrivals” replace people moving northward? Or a city whose population collapses as rising sea levels eliminate our beaches and land area? No one knows for sure, particularly as our role will probably change over the decades. This is not a disguised NIMBY argument but is founded on the fact that humans are only comfortable in a very limited temperature range. And lest this discussion sound theoretical, note that every weekend our city hosts thousands of climate refugees disguised as beachgoers cooked out of their homes in the San Fernando Valley and central Los Angeles.

Given those uncertainties, prudence says we should take a middle path: e.g. our population should not increase faster than our region, which itself is responding to the same global pressures. In this manner, we do our regional part, yet we give ourselves time to adjust our mobility infrastructure, our ecological goals, our police and fire services and all our other limited resoutces to this increased population.

SM.a.r.t. suggests that our construction approvals should not exceed the population growth rate of Los Angeles County. For example, the annual growth rate of Los Angeles County over the last 7.5 years to mid-2017 averaged 0.43 percent year. In the last year alone Santa Monica approved projects whose projected population is equal to a 0.92 percent per year growth rate. In other words last year we grew at twice the average rate of L.A. County. As population growth and construction rates fluctuate wildly annually, we should consider using, for example, a 5 year average to set our construction limit benchmarks.

But what about the housing crisis? There is not a housing crisis but an housing affordability crisis. Santa Monica produces plenty of housing: about 500 units were approved in 2017. But we produce too few affordable units: for example the typical 47 unit building approved at 2903 Lincoln Blvd. has only four dedicated affordable units. Our current construction ratio of market rate to affordable units is essentially a gentrification factory pushing out poorer residents and the businesses that serve them to favor new wealthy arrivals and foreign investors. This is not to say we should not have a robust affordable housing program, but to understand clearly we cannot currently build our way to affordability.

Basing our population growth on County growth is not a sufficient measure because our effective population is not only our 94,000 residents. There’s another larger population that mostly invades the city in the daytime: visitors, students, commuters, workers, shoppers, and tourists: well over another 100,000 persons. Because we live in a desertifying climate, water becomes the inevitable local (and state wide) choke point. In the last drought our residents lowered their water usage faster than commercial users which actually raised their water usage. In other words the residents subsidized with increased rates, the water use of profligate businesses, a large fraction of whose usage serves non-residents. We are now drawing our well water supplies down faster than are being replenished and still get one third of our water from increasingly vulnerable (east of the San Andreas fault) and ultimately declining (e.g. Sierra snowpack) sources.

The City is rolling out a great program that requires new developments not to use more water than the existing usage on the lot where the project is being proposed. Or they can create equivalent savings by for example installing sufficient low flow toilets in other buildings to make up for that increase. This is a great beginning but must be extended to the entire city. There is a State law that requires developments over 500 units to show new sources of water sufficient for that development. But we approve the equivalent of 500 new units every year however have yet to show any new water sources. Until new sustainable water sources are available, the City should not approve any project that increases our water use. Again this may sound draconian, but take the current example of Capetown, South Africa, which has about the same population as Los Angeles City and will literally run out of water in about three months.

Currently State law precludes cities setting a numerical population cap, but there is nothing that precludes cities from limiting their rate of growth. Because Santa Monica City Council has not taken seriously a public discussion about the limits to growth, it’s not surprising we have had a regular series of populist uprisings in the form of Prop T, the LUVE initiative, and now term limits.

It is time that, as a city, we establish limits to growth. Two easy to measure and politically sellable limits that should be considered are population increase rate and water usage. Failure to plan ahead is a plan to fail.

By Mario Fonda-Bonardi AIA for Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow

Sam Tolkin, Architect; Dan Jansenson Building and Safety Commissioner, Architect; Mario Fonda-Bonardi, AIA, Planning Commissioner; Ron Goldman, FAIA; Thane Roberts, AIA; Bob. Taylor, AIA; Phil Brock, Arts Commissioner.

Related Posts

The Brian Jonestown Massacre Drops New Double A-Side Ahead of U.S. Tour

April 24, 2025

April 24, 2025

Legendary Psych-Rockers Set April 25 Release and Fall North American Tour The Brian Jonestown Massacre is set to release a...

(Video) Matú Kai Brentwood: The full experience

April 23, 2025

April 23, 2025

Sister restaurant to Matú in Beverly Hills, located at 11777 San Vicente Blvd. Sister restaurant to Matú in Beverly Hills,...

Uncle Stevey’s Bagels Wins Westside Hearts with Next-Level Bagels, Premium Sandwiches, and Local Coffee

April 23, 2025

April 23, 2025

Family-Run Shop Serves Delicious and Thoughtfully Curated Bagels With Love By Dolores Quintana A little more than a year since...

Santa Monica’s Socalo Toasts Pali Wine Co. with a Five-Course Culinary Celebration

April 23, 2025

April 23, 2025

Enjoy Celebrated Central Coast Wines, Including a 100-Point Red Blend Socalo, the acclaimed Mexican restaurant from celebrity chefs Mary Sue...

Go Go Bird Teams Up with Chef Chris Oh for Korean-Inspired Fried Chicken Sandwich

April 23, 2025

April 23, 2025

Crispy, Saucy, Spicy: Chris Oh’s Fried Chicken Sandwich Lands in Culver City Go Go Bird, located in Culver City’s Citizen...

Fogo de Chão Hosts Wine Lover’s Dream Night with Chilean Winery VIK

April 23, 2025

April 23, 2025

Diners Will Enjoy a Chef-Curated South American Menu, Highly Rated Wines Wine lovers and culinary connoisseurs are invited to gather...

(Video) A Myriad of Ways to Unlock Your Beauty Offered at Mirror Mirror Med Spa

April 23, 2025

April 23, 2025

For More Info, Go To Mirrormedspa.com For More Info, Go To https://t.co/5uE3LO9Lz9 pic.twitter.com/tz8YgJaB4j — Westside Today (@WestsideLAToday) April 23, 2025

New York Film Academy in Los Angeles Offers Summer Camps, Programs

April 22, 2025

April 22, 2025

New York Film Academy in Los Angeles is hosting several summer camps for teenagers and kids, providing practical training in...

Cinespia Returns to Hollywood Forever With Cult Classics and a David Lynch Tribute

April 22, 2025

April 22, 2025

Hollywood Forever Cemetery Becomes a Moviegoer’s Paradise Once Again Cinespia, Los Angeles’ beloved outdoor cinema series, will return to Hollywood...

Major I-405 Rehab Project Unveiled: Caltrans to Host Virtual Info Meeting

April 22, 2025

April 22, 2025

Sepulveda Pass Overhaul: New Pavement, Safer Roads, Better Commutes The California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) will hold a virtual informational...

Culver City Government Hosts Second Annual Mental Health Fair at City Hall

April 22, 2025

April 22, 2025

Free Tools, Resources, and Relaxing Activities at Wellness Celebration Culver City will host its second annual Mental Health Resource Fair...

Skip Traffic, Relax, Catch a Vibe: Midweek Sunset Party Lands on the Westside

April 22, 2025

April 22, 2025

DJ Jason Bentley, Mocktails, Games, Food Trucks, Light Up Fox Hills Commuters looking to escape rush hour gridlock on Thursday,...

San Fernando Valley Man Gets 5 Years for Beverly Hills Bank Fraud and Identity Theft

April 22, 2025

April 22, 2025

Federal Prison for ID Thief Who Raided Beverly Hills Mailboxes for Millions A North Hills man was sentenced Monday to...

Santa Monica Police to Target Impaired Drivers at DUI Checkpoint 

April 22, 2025

April 22, 2025

Officers Will Be On Alert for Alcohol and Drug Impairment The Santa Monica Police Department announced plans to conduct a...

Academy Announces Major Changes for 98th Oscars, Including AI Rules and New Casting Award

April 22, 2025

April 22, 2025

Academy Now Requires Viewing All Nominees to Cast Final Ballots The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences has unveiled...