September 30, 2023 The Best Source of News, Culture, Lifestyle for Culver City, Mar Vista, Del Rey, Palms and West Los Angeles

SMa.r.t.-Sacramento Tries to Nuke Santa Monica (again)

By Mario Fonda-Bonardi AIA

Legislation would see 95 percent of Santa Monica bypass zoning codes.

When it first appeared it was almost a joke, some kind of bizarre nightmare; a State senator from San Francisco recently introduced legislation to encourage new housing production throughout the state. SB-827 would do away with all zoning restrictions within a half-mile of a train station, a quarter-mile of a frequent bus route, and a half-mile of any intersection of frequent bus routes. Any housing built in those areas would be free of any local restrictions on height, size, parking requirements, floor area ratio, or number of units.

According to SB-827, any lot, no matter its zoning, could have apartment buildings of up to 85’ or eight stories built on it (lots less than 45’ wide could go up to six stories). This includes single-family residential lots, buildings on the state historic register, and properties containing two- or three-story apartment buildings similar to those containing most of Santa Monica’s rent-controlled units. It also includes the entirety of the city’s ocean-facing neighborhood along Ocean Boulevard. None would be spared. The text of the measure can be seen here: https://tinyurl.com/y84a4l8g.

A first glance at a map of Santa Monica shows that 95 percent of the city would be subject to this measure, if it passes. In other words, any Santa Monica lot wider than 45’ could have an eight story building on it by right: with no local objection permitted. As such it completely destroys the recently approved Downtown Specific Plan and demolishes totally our Land Use Circulation Element which is supposed to govern development of the entire city for 20 years. Such blanket legislation is identical to the recent poison pill foisted on us by State law that Environmental Impact Reports cannot consider traffic impacts if the projects are within a quarter mile of any transit stop. This State law makes questioning proposed traffic impacts of future projects, which is a major issue in Santa Monica, totally irrelevant and ineffective.

Such legislation coming out of Sacramento is typical of the arrogance of those who think that to every complex problem there is always a simple, easy, and quick solution. In this case the simple, easy, and quick solution to housing affordability issues is to abolish planning regulations and local control. More often than not these easy solutions are wrong. Remember Sacramento created Santa Monica’s housing affordability issue years ago by passing vacancy decontrol which neutered our rent control laws and moved at least half of Santa Monica’s rent controlled units from affordable to unaffordable market rates. Likewise whenever Sacramento gets involved in what are essentially local issues, it tells you that the special interests have failed to convince the natives that the simple minded solution being proposed has merit and now are trying to bring big brother’s force to bear by weaponizing State laws to legally trump local ordinances and preferences. In other words San Francisco’s Senator Weiner, who introduced the bill, has failed to convince his constituency, at the local level, to cover San Francisco with eight story buildings, so he’s now trying to sell this trojan horse to the entire state.

The reason why his sales pitch is gaining any traction is that a quantity and affordability panic has been created, and now suddenly any solution, even the most misguided ones must be adopted. Panic is a poor basis for public decisions: panic brought us Manzanar, created Senator Joseph Mc Carthy, and is now trying to “build a wall”.

The sober reality is that Santa Monica’s robust construction and affordable housing program is doing its part to solve the State’s housing shortfall.

  • Our city’s population is growing faster than the average for our metropolitan area.
  • We consistently meet and exceed all of Southern Counties Association of Government housing production quotas.
  • Using a liberal accessory dwelling unit code we have effectively eliminated all the R-1 districts and rezoned the entire city to allow two units, with some modest limitations, on any lot with an existing single family residence.
  • We extract modest but real affordable unit requirements from all major projects and require substantial affordable unit fees for other smaller projects.
  • The citizens have imposed on themselves a sales tax that will produce about 20 affordable units per year for every year in the foreseeable future.
  • In spite of Sacramento’s meddling, we still have a rent control ordinance and political backup protecting tenant’s rights.

In other words Santa Monica is doing more than its part, unlike some cities such as Beverly Hills, to provide both quantity and affordable housing. We are doing all these things on some of the priciest California coastal land, in a built-out city, in a time of exceptionally high construction costs. We are doing all this knowing Santa Monica cannot build its way to affordability since there is an infinite demand of wealthy people wanting to live here but a very limited amount of water, space and sunlight to power our green city. We could double the number of units in the city, make it look like Hong Kong or Honolulu, and there would still be an affordability crisis as new units always cost more than old units.

Santa Monica does not need to frantically respond to panic from Sacramento. SB-827 should die a quiet death and Senator Weiner should go back ruining his own city and leave all the other California cities to work out their own appropriate response to housing issues.

SMa.r.t.: Thane Roberts AIA, Architect, Robert H. Taylor AIA, Ron Goldman FAIA, Architect, Dan Jansenson, Architect, Building and Fire-Life Safety Commission, Samuel Tolkin Architect, Mario Fonda-Bonardi, AIA, Planning Commissioner, Phil Brock, Santa Monica Arts Commission

SMa.r.t. (Santa Monica Architects for a Responsible Tomorrow). Thane Roberts AIA, Architect, Robert H. Taylor AIA, Mario Fonda-Bonardi AIA, Daniel Jansenson Architect, Samuel Tolkin AIA, Phil Brock, Santa Monica Arts Commission.

Related Posts

Total Wine & More Celebrates Grand Opening in Culver City

September 29, 2023

September 29, 2023

Store Wants to Make a Contribution to the Community  By Keemia Zhang Total Wine & More celebrated the grand opening...

Recent Culver City Police Department Gun Buyback Event Exceeds Expectations

September 29, 2023

September 29, 2023

Collaborative Event Hosted by CCPD and The Boy Scouts Was Successful By Dolores Quintana The recent gun buyback event held...

New Lawsuit Seeks to Repeal the City’s Homeless Emergency Declaration

September 29, 2023

September 29, 2023

Westside Non-Profit Has Filed Lawsuit in Los Angeles Superior Court By Dolores Quintana A nonprofit organization from the Westside of...

California’s Legal Shift: Cash Bail System Ends On Sunday For Certain Defendants

September 29, 2023

September 29, 2023

Despite Opposition to Proposition, California Supreme Court Ruled Against System By Dolores Quintana A landmark ruling by the California Supreme...

(Video) Home State Is Now Open In Culver City

September 28, 2023

September 28, 2023

The Popular Tex-Mex Taco Spot Had a Lot of Business On Opening Day. @HomeState @culvercitywlanews Home State Is Now Open...

Get Ready to Satisfy Your Pumpkin Cravings with See’s Candies’ Limited-Time Delights

September 28, 2023

September 28, 2023

Fall for Flavor: See’s Candies Unveils Irresistible Pumpkin Treats By Dolores Quintana As the cozy weather of autumn settles in,...

Revolutionize Your Coffee Experience: Blue Bottle’s Exclusive Residency Unveiled

September 28, 2023

September 28, 2023

A Full Flavor Coffee Experience With Dessert Meant For Savoring  By Dolores Quintana Blue Bottle Coffee, a well-known specialty coffee...

Join Tito’s Fiesta Mexicana for Tantalizing Tacos, Tito’s Vodka, and a Mariachi Extravaganza

September 28, 2023

September 28, 2023

Spectacular Yearly Event To Tempt Your Taste Buds, Bring Community Together For Charity By Dolores Quintana Tito’s Tacos and Tito’s...

Hollywood Twist: Writers Guild Strikes Gold with Extraordinary Deal

September 26, 2023

September 26, 2023

WGA Members To Vote On Ratification of the Tentative Contract  By Dolores Quintana  After The Writers Guild of America (WGA)...

Film Review: Amerikatsi

September 26, 2023

September 26, 2023

FILM REVIEWAmerikatsiUnrated117 MinutesReleased September 8, 2023 A storyline predominantly based on voyeurism is not a new cinematic concept, and here...

Culver City’s Exchange Club’s 2023 Fiesta La Ballona Beer and Wine Garden Fundraiser Reaches New Heights

September 26, 2023

September 26, 2023

The Group Announces the Amount of Funds Raised At Fiesta La Ballona For Charity By Dolores Quintana The Exchange Club...

(Video) Total Wine & More Opens Culver City Location

September 26, 2023

September 26, 2023

With a wide selection of wine, beer, alcohol, snacks, and accessories, you can find almost anything you need. Total Wine...

Los Angeles Residents See No Relief in Sight For The Price of Gas

September 26, 2023

September 26, 2023

Disappointment at the Pump For Drivers In The City  By Dolores Quintana On Monday, the relentless upward trend of the...

Culver City Police Quickly Arrest Suspected Burglar After Traffic Violation

September 26, 2023

September 26, 2023

Traffic Stop Yields Evidence In Other Crime In West Los Angeles By Dolores Quintana According to a press release from...

Film Review: Bottoms

September 26, 2023

September 26, 2023

FILM REVIEWBOTTOMSRated R91 MinutesReleased August 25th Welcome to a new generation of breakout stars of American comedy who make the...