November 5, 2024 The Best Source of News, Culture, Lifestyle for Culver City, Mar Vista, Del Rey, Palms and West Los Angeles

Court Rules Purple Line Studies OK

Purple Line
A judge ruled the Purple Line’s environmental studies were valid. (Image courtesy of Metro)

A lawsuit filed by Beverly Hills City Hall and the City’s school district challenging the validity of Metro’s Purple Line environmental studies suffered a judicious blow on April 2, as a judge ruled in favor of the transit agency moving forward with the Westside Subway Extension project as currently planned.

Both the City of Beverly Hills and the Beverly Hills Unified School District (BHUSD) sued the Metro and claimed the agency’s environmental studies of the Purple Line’s planned station at Avenue of the Stars and Constellation in Century City were defective.

However, Superior Court judge John A. Torribio found the environmental studies were valid and Metro’s approval of the Purple Line Extension – also referred to as the Westside Subway Extension – through Beverly Hills and into Century City “was based on substantial evidence.”

BHUSD joined the City of Beverly Hills in the lawsuit because a portion of the Purple Line subway would travel underneath Beverly Hills High School (BHHS) just shy of the Century City station at Avenue of the Stars and Constellation Avenue.

City Hall and the school district argued Metro violated the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) by prematurely releasing the Draft Environmental Impact Report (EIR) and failed to consider all viable alternatives before deciding upon tunneling underneath BHHS.

In his ruling, Torribio stated the project description in the Draft EIR was “accurate, stable, and finite.” Even more, Torribio ruled there were no CEQA violations by Metro or within any released versions of the EIR.

Both City Hall and the BHUSD hoped the court would rule in its favor and ultimately have the Century City station removed from Avenue of the Stars and Constellation Avenue and relocated to a location on Santa Monica Boulevard. By moving the station slightly to the north, the alignment of Purple Line’s route through Beverly Hills and under BHHS would presumably be altered.

Torribio stated moving the station away from Avenue of the Stars and Constellation Avenue would not only take away from the Purple Line’s practicality but also place it in danger of being even closer to a fault line than it is already.

“The [Draft EIR] properly discloses that the Project area lies within a seismically active region, and that the feasibility of the Santa Monica station is compromised by the Santa Monica Fault Zone,” Torribio stated in his ruling.

“The Constellation Station is located in the middle of high rise office buildings that house thousands of potential subway riders. SM Station would require these same riders to walk a considerable distance to access the subway. Therefore, substantial evidence supports Metro’s decision to approve Constellation Station as a more viable alternative than [Santa Monica Boulevard] Station,” he continued.

Purple Line
A key issue in the lawsuit: tunneling underneath Beverly Hills High School. (Thinkstock)

Beverly Hills City Hall and BHHUSD also claimed the Constellation Station was located on an active fault, a contention Torribio rejected as “clearly erroneous or inaccurate.”

“Metro undertook significant analysis of the subsurface structure of the [Constellation] Station site, including review of historical data, review of previous fault investigations performed in Century City, and new borings, cone penetration tests, and observation wells,” Torribio stated in his ruling.

The lawsuit also alleged Metro violated Beverly Hills’ due process and failed to have the Draft EIR re-circulated and revised in multiple rounds. Further, the lawsuit contended air quality would be adversely impacted during construction and the mitigation of construction traffic was not properly analyzed.

Two unique claims were also raised by City Hall and school district, including allegations the Final EIR “never addressed the danger posed by drilling” through subsurface gas and Metro failed to “identify unmapped oil wells within the Project area, but deferred this task until after Project approval.”

Torribio refuted both claims in his ruling, stating Metro “reasonably concluded that tunneling can safely be constructed and operated in gassy ground” and the Purple Line’s design would avoid the unmapped oil wells.

“Metro is pleased that our in-depth, multi-year environmental review process was found valid by the Superior Court,” read a statement issued by Metro. “We look forward to working with all the communities along the alignment, including Beverly Hills, to fulfill our commitment to deliver this regionally significant and beneficial project for the taxpayers of L.A. County.”

According to Metro, the Purple Line Extension would add 8.5 miles of subway rail to the already existing east-west route that currently runs from Union Station to Wilshire Boulevard and Western Avenue in Koreatown.

A three-phase project, the first leg of the subway extension project would bring the Purple Line from its current Koreatown terminus to Wilshire and La Cienega boulevards. The second phase would extend the Purple Line into Century City before the final construction would complete the route through to the Veterans Administration building in Westwood.

Purple Line
A Metro subway station. (Thinkstock)

Construction is expected to begin later this year and, according to Metro, the first phase of the subway is planned to open in 2023.

BHUSD and the City of Beverly Hills still have federal lawsuits pending, according to Metro. Specifically, both the City and school district filed suit against the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) and reportedly alleged National Environmental Act Policy violations. Metro stated the FTA provided some funding and approved the environmental studies for the Purple Line Extension.

In a separate matter, the Beverly Hills City Council approved at its April 1 meeting a pair of permits allowing Metro to conduct groundwater and gas sampling activities as well as relocating underground utilities as part of the Westside Subway Extension.

Related Posts

Election Day Freebies and Discounts: Where to Eat, Drink, and Watch Election Results

November 4, 2024

November 4, 2024

From Free Doughnuts To Watch Parties, How To Unwind With Election Night Deals With this election day being one of...

Early Morning Call From Community Leads to Burglary Arrest in Culver City

November 4, 2024

November 4, 2024

Police Respond To Suspicious Activity Call, Arrest Suspect With Pickaxe Culver City police arrested a man early Friday morning in...

Culver City Police Department is Prepared to Ensure Community Safety During Election Week

November 4, 2024

November 4, 2024

Enhanced Patrols, Activated Emergency Center Ready, Culver City Voting Center is Open The Culver City Police Department has announced an...

Legendary Music Icon Quincy Jones Dies at 91 in Bel Air

November 4, 2024

November 4, 2024

Celebrated Musician, Producer Leaves an Indelible Legacy By Dolores Quintana Legendary musician, music producer, film and television producer, composer of...

Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences Lays Off Longtime Archive and Library Staff

November 4, 2024

November 4, 2024

Downsizing and Restructuring Continue, Affecting Employees with Decades of Service By Dolores Quintana Last week, the Academy of Motion Picture...

LA County Opens 526 New Vote Centers for Early Voting, Announces Conditional Voting for Unregistered Residents

November 3, 2024

November 3, 2024

Metro LA Offers Free Rides on Election Day to Help Residents Get to the Polls Los Angeles County opened an...

New Aviation/Century Station Opens, Linking Metro’s C and K Lines

November 3, 2024

November 3, 2024

Metro’s Newest Station Paves the Way for Future LAX Transit Center The new Aviation/Century Station officially opened this week, marking...

H5N1 Detected in LA County Wastewater, Health Officials Urge Precautions for Residents

November 3, 2024

November 3, 2024

Los Angeles County Investigates Low-Level H5 Avian Flu Detected in Wastewater The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health is...

Two Events in Culver City This Weekend: Bike Registration and Dance Performance

November 1, 2024

November 1, 2024

Put the Brakes on Bicycle Theft and Enjoy an Evening of Dance and Interactive Art The Culver City Police Department...

All You Need to Know to Attend the Dodgers Victory Parade Tomorrow in DTLA

November 1, 2024

November 1, 2024

World Champions and LA’s Team to Greet Angelenos After Win of NY Yankees The Los Angeles Dodgers announced that their...

Beverly Hills City Government Agrees to a Stipulated Judgment After Blocking Abortion Clinic Opening

November 1, 2024

November 1, 2024

City to Implement Training, Oversight on Reproductive Rights Following Legal Settlement  California Attorney General Rob Bonta announced a legal agreement...

Dia De Los Muertos 2024: Here’s Where To Celebrate The Holiday Tradition This Weekend

October 31, 2024

October 31, 2024

Los Angeles Has a Variety of Ways to Explore Latino Culture and Honor Ancestors Starting just after Halloween, Dia de...

(Video) Downtown L.A. Reacts to World Series Victory

October 31, 2024

October 31, 2024

The Dodgers Are World Series Champs For The Eighth Time https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTFtyDDKn/

Halloween Pre-Game Party Brings Chills and Spooky Thrills to The Rose Venice

October 31, 2024

October 31, 2024

Enjoy Halloween With Festive Cocktails, Appetizers, and a Costume Contest The Rose Venice in Venice is set to host a...

(Video) Something About Her’s First Tea Time Was a Big Hit

October 31, 2024

October 31, 2024

The Next Date is November Third. Beautiful vibes, deciduous food and drink. Don’t miss it. @Something About Her @culvercitywlanews Something...