September 26, 2023 The Best Source of News, Culture, Lifestyle for Culver City, Mar Vista, Del Rey, Palms and West Los Angeles

Jury awards woman $28.2 million in suit against Kaiser Permanente

(Thinkstock)
(Thinkstock)

A Chatsworth woman who sued her Kaiser health plan alleging delays in authorizing an MRI when she was a teenager caused a cancerous tumor to grow and forced the amputation of her right leg, was awarded $28.2 million by a jury today.

The Los Angeles Superior Court panel deliberated for about a day before finding that Southern California Permanente Medical Group was negligent in the treatment of Anna Rahm, now 23.

She was not present for the verdict, but many of the jurors smiled at her parents as they walked out of the courtroom.

The jury awarded medical expenses and lost earnings with a future value of $26.3 million. The remainder will compensate Rahm for her past and future pain and suffering.

“At Kaiser Permanente, the health and safety of our patients is paramount at all times,”  Peggy Hinz, Kaiser Permanente’s director of communications, told City News Service.

“Although we understand the jury’s findings and wish only the best for Ms. Rahm, highly respected medical experts testified that the medical care provided was appropriate. We will be evaluating in the days ahead how best to respond to this verdict.”

Rahm’s attorney, Michael Bidart, told the jury that two Kaiser doctors ignored medical red flags that should have told them an MRI was immediately necessary.

Bidart said only the persistence of the girl’s mother, Lynette, ultimately forced Dr. Charlene Huang to clear the way for the procedure in July 2009, four months after the Rahms first requested it.

Defense attorney N. Denise Taylor countered that Huang and Dr. Ngan Voung wanted to try conservative treatment before resorting to more aggressive measures. She said the trial evidence showed the teen’s cancer had reached her spine when the physicians treated her in March 2009 and that time was thus not the factor Bidart suggests when it came to ordering the MRI.

“Once her spine is involved, her leg has to come off,” Taylor said.

Rahm filed suit in June 2010. Her court papers stated that she was 16 years old when she began having back pain in August 2008 that grew worse over time. Her family’s chiropractor in February 2009 ordered that X-rays be taken of her back, but a radiologist not affiliated with Kaiser concluded the teen’s condition was normal, according to the lawsuit. The chiropractor recommended that she get an MRI from Kaiser, according to Rahm’s court papers.

Bidart and Taylor gave different accounts of what Rahm and her mother told Huang, Rahm’s primary care physician, and Vuong, a specialist in physical medicine.

Bidart said Rahm’s mother requested MRIs for her daughter from both doctors, but Taylor said neither physician recalled her making such a request.

Bidart said Huang finally relented in June 2009 and the MRI was performed the next month, showing a malignant tumor in Rahm’s pelvis, Bidart said. In October 2009 she underwent surgery to remove her right leg and half of her pelvis.

“A less aggressive surgery could have been performed if her cancer had been diagnosed earlier,” Bidart said, saying Rahm’s leg could have been saved.

Bidart said Rahm was “right up to death’s doorstep” and that she would have died had her cancer not been discovered and surgically removed.

“Anna Rahm deserved to have a timely and prompt diagnosis of her disease,” Bidart said.

Bidart said the doctors tried to blame Rahm and her mother in part for what happened, saying they should have come back for appointments sooner.

However, Taylor told jurors that Rahm had a rare form of cancer that was even more unusual in young women her age and that the two doctors who treated her were not negligent.

“It was not anyone at Kaiser’s fault,” Taylor said.

Taylor said only a handful of doctors nationwide know how to perform the surgery the plaintiff received. She said the woman is now cancer-free, is working and has a full expectation of living up to her normal life expectancy of another 59 years.

“She has indisputably had an excellent result,” Taylor said of Rahm’s post-surgery progress. “You would be inhuman if you didn’t have sympathy for her. But this case is not about sympathy. It’s about whether the two doctors complied with the standard of care.”

Related Posts

Mixed-Use West Edge Development Unveiled North of Expo/Bundy Station In Sawtelle

September 25, 2023

September 25, 2023

Development is a collaboration between Hines, Affinius Capital, and Philena Properties  By Dolores Quintana The once-familiar site of the Martin...

Writers Guild and AMPTP Reach Tentative Agreement After 146-Day Strike

September 25, 2023

September 25, 2023

Picketing Is Suspended For Now, Contract Language To Be Finalized By Dolores Quintana Around 7:30 p.m. tonight, the Writers Guild...

Rising Mortgage Rates and Low Inventory Continue to Impact California Home Sales

September 24, 2023

September 24, 2023

California’s Median Home Price Records Its Highest Year-Over-Year Gain in 15 Months By Dolores Quintana California home sales faced their...

Join Heal the Bay for the Official Coastal Cleanup Day on Saturday, September 23

September 21, 2023

September 21, 2023

Make a Difference in Your Community by Removing Trash From Our Coast By Dolores Quintana On Saturday, September 23, 2023,...

Fatal Collision Involving Auto and Motorcycle On September 20 in Palms

September 21, 2023

September 21, 2023

Tragic Incident Prompts Swift Response by Los Angeles Firefighters By Dolores Quintana A tragic auto versus motorcycle collision unfolded at...

COVIDTests.gov to Reopen for Free Testing Starting on September 25

September 21, 2023

September 21, 2023

HHS Invests $600 Million in Domestic COVID-19 Test Manufacturing By Dolores Quintana The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services...

(Video) Citizen Public Market’s New Expanded Rooftop Bar Area

September 21, 2023

September 21, 2023

The rooftop bar’s size has been doubled and offers a relaxing and al fresco area for patrons to enjoy cocktails,...

Shake Shack Introduces Pilot Program with Eco-Friendly Oil

September 21, 2023

September 21, 2023

Zero Acre Farms to partner with Shake Shack in NYC  By Keemia Zhang Shake Shack has announced a partnership with...

Pringles and Caviar Company Introduce New Tiktok-Inspired Collaboration

September 20, 2023

September 20, 2023

TikTok Trend Spurs Special Partnership Between Brands By Keemia Zhang ​Pringles and The Caviar Co. have collaborated to produce the...

Exclusive: One of the West Coast’s Most Celebrated Ice Cream Shops To Open in Brentwood

September 20, 2023

September 20, 2023

Interview With Co-Founder Kim Malek Talks About Their Hopes For Their New Shop By Dolores Quintana It’s been six long...

Breakfast Burritos, Coffee, and Texas Style Tacos Have Arrived In Culver City

September 20, 2023

September 20, 2023

Two Popular Spots Famous For Their Breakfast Burritos Are Now Open By Dolores Quintana The news went out today among...

Culver City Council Highlights: Leadership Sponsorship, Tax Penalties, and Community Honors

September 19, 2023

September 19, 2023

Monday’s City Council Meeting Addresses Key Issues and Commemorates Former Mayor By Dolores Quintana The Culver City City Council convened...

Union Solidarity Coalition Creates Charity Auction to Support Industry Workers Amidst 2023 WGA Strike

September 19, 2023

September 19, 2023

Showbiz Memorabilia, Personal Meetings, Celebrity Dogwalking Among Auction Items By Dolores Quintana The Writers Guild strike against The Alliance of...

Los Angeles Launches ERAP to Prevent Homelessness Amidst Rent Crisis

September 19, 2023

September 19, 2023

United to House Los Angeles Program Offers Vital Rental Assistance By Dolores Quintana The United to House Los Angeles (ULA)...

Phoenix House 5K Walk Fights Opioid Crisis, Raises Overdose Awareness

September 18, 2023

September 18, 2023

Inaugural Walk Seeks To Unite Community and Show Support To Families By Dolores Quintana Phoenix Houses of California, a prominent...