November 5, 2024 The Best Source of News, Culture, Lifestyle for Culver City, Mar Vista, Del Rey, Palms and West Los Angeles

HOA Homefront: Brokers Weigh in on ‘Bare Walls’ Insurance Plans

By Kelly G. Richardson

So-called “bare walls” insurance plans are often discussed in associations trying to limit the cost of water damage claims.

In a bare walls approach, the HOA insurance does not restore unit interiors. It’s up to each owner to insure (via individual HO6 policy) or pay for their own cabinets, wall and floor coverings, and other interior finishes. I consulted several leading insurance brokers on the subject.

The experts did not agree on the desirability of a bare walls system. Steven Segal, of the Steven G. Segal Insurance Agency in Sherman Oaks, observed there is “too much exposure both to the association and the individual unit owner.” John Sinner, of the John R. Sinner Insurance Agency in Alhambra, disfavors bare walls insurance, because “it leaves the responsibility of proper interior insurance on the owners.” Sinner said if a unit owner had insufficient interior coverage, the association might have a damaged unit left only partially restored. Joel Meskin, Managing Director of McGowan Program Administrators, a national agency headquartered in Ohio, also does not recommend bare walls insurance, questioning whether unit owners will obtain their own HO6 insurance policies.  He said further “I have much more confidence in the association taking care of the issues, and I think the [cost of] insurance obtained by the association will be ultimately be less than the totality of changing to bare walls.” Sinner said if a unit owner had insufficient interior coverage, the association might have a damaged unit left only partially restored.

Joel Meskin, Managing Director of McGowan Program Administrators, a national agency headquartered in Ohio, also does not recommend bare walls insurance, questioning whether unit owners will obtain their own HO6 insurance policies. He said further “I have much more confidence in the association taking care of the issues, and I think the [cost of] insurance obtained by the association will ultimately be less than the totality of changing to bare walls.”

However, Michael Berg of the Berg Insurance Agency in Lake Forest, offered a differing view: “Bare walls is the most equitable sharing of the risk of damage to interior property.  It most closely aligns with the maintenance and repair responsibilities of the HOA and the unit owner.” Steven S. Grane, of Alante Insurance Services in Irvine, said a bare walls policy “eliminates multiple claims against the HOA master policy. The more claims, the higher the premium.”

Is the total cost of all the individual HO6 policies and HOA “bare walls” insurance less expensive than a more comprehensive HOA policy?  John Sinner believes it might not

Sinner believes it might not be, and could cost more. Segal agrees, saying the increased cost to each owner may be more than the difference between “bare walls” and full HOA coverage. Per Michael Berg, the breakeven point will depend on the size of the insurance and how much the carrier is charging for coverage of property attached to unit interiors.

However, Timothy Cline of the Cline Insurance Agency in West Los Angeles said that “simply adding an endorsement that broadens (“walls in”) or narrows the scope (“bare walls”) has virtually no impact on the rate.” Cline said the rate is more affected by the amount of property coverage.

The experts agreed that individual unit owners should have HO6 policies, regardless of the association’s insurance approach.

To save money on insurance premiums, Segal and Sinner recommended associations obtain a modification, or “endorsement,” to their policy which removes floor and wall coverings from the association insurance coverage.

All this brings three conclusions. First, HOAs should discuss the costs and benefits of each alternative with their insurance broker and legal counsel. Second, condominium owners should have their own individual HO6 policies, regardless of what their HOA does (or doesn’t).  Finally, one approach does not fit all – each association’s approach should be tailored to its needs and unique characteristics.

Homeowner's Association Homefront

Related Posts

5 Strategies for Entrepreneurs to Succeed in the Gaming Industry

October 15, 2024

October 15, 2024

Gaming is one of the most competitive industries in the world. For entrepreneurs, this industry offers many opportunities but also...

8 Places to Spend Crypto in LA

September 2, 2024

September 2, 2024

Los Angeles is a vibrant city known for its innovative spirit, and as cryptocurrencies gain traction, many local businesses are...

The Best Sites Where You Can Buy TikTok Followers

September 2, 2024

September 2, 2024

TikTok has been popular as a social media platform with its creativity and popularity. Since it’s the case, many of...

Bitcoin Mining in Los Angeles and Its Economic Impact

August 12, 2024

August 12, 2024

Once a quirky computer pastime for the geek squad, bitcoin mining has become a significant economic force in places like...

How to Stay Safe While Enjoying Digital Entertainment in West LA

August 5, 2024

August 5, 2024

Recent developments have shown that so much of people’s daily lives are centered on the internet. A 2021 survey conducted...

Why Choose Local Florists for Your Flower Delivery?

May 12, 2024

May 12, 2024

Finding local florists has become easier than ever with the advent of digital marketplaces. Opting for Nashville flower delivery near...

8 Essential Things to Do After a Car Accident in Las Vegas

April 16, 2024

April 16, 2024

A car crash can be extremely traumatic for the people involved in it. Even if there is no major injury...

8 Essential Things to Do After a CarAccident in Las Vegas

April 8, 2024

April 8, 2024

A car crash can be extremely traumatic for the people involved in it. Even if there is no major injury...

Foreign Currency in International Business Expansion

January 2, 2024

January 2, 2024

Business has transformed into a whole different dimension. The interconnectedness across countries is increasing the feasibility of business expansions. It...

How to Select Quality Solar Panels and Installation in California

January 2, 2024

January 2, 2024

As solar energy becomes more affordable and popular, many homeowners in California are considering installing solar panels. However, not all...

Celebrating Christmas in Las Vegas: A Winter Wonderland of Fun and Festivity

November 15, 2023

November 15, 2023

As the festive season approaches, Las Vegas transforms into a glittering winter wonderland, offering a unique and magical Christmas experience....

Navigating Oxnard’s Public Transportation System: A Driver’s Guide

November 2, 2023

November 2, 2023

Whether you live in Oxnard or want to visit, it’s useful to know how to get around this coastal city....

15 Tips For Keeping Burglars Out Of Your Business

October 16, 2023

October 16, 2023

In the ever-evolving realm of business security, the persistent threat of burglary perpetually looms overhead like a dark cloud. The...

US Gambling Laws

July 12, 2023

July 12, 2023

Whilst casino gaming is a significant part of the American culture, US gambling laws are ever-changing. Prior to the Unlawful...

Reasonable Renting in The City of Angels

June 2, 2023

June 2, 2023

What would it be like to wake up in a bustling metropolis filled with endless possibilities, set against rows of...