November 14, 2024 The Best Source of News, Culture, Lifestyle for Culver City, Mar Vista, Del Rey, Palms and West Los Angeles

State Supreme Court Orders Re-Sentencing for Get-Away Driver Convicted in Security Guard’s Killing at Medical Marijuana Clinic

(Thinkstock).
(Thinkstock).

The California Supreme Court Thursday found “insufficient evidence” to support a special circumstance allegation that had sent a man to prison for life without the possibility of parole for being the getaway driver in a botched robbery at a medical marijuana clinic in Los Angeles where a security guard was shot to death.

The state’s highest court ordered the case against Lovie Troy Matthews to be sent back to Los Angeles Superior Court for re-sentencing, but it was not immediately clear how long of a sentence he could now face.

Matthews was convicted of first-degree murder, attempted robbery and commercial burglary.

Jurors had also found true a special circumstance allegation that Noe Campos Gonzales was murdered during the commission of an attempted robbery or burglary.

But the California Supreme Court unanimously found that “the evidence was insufficient as a matter of law to support the special circumstance” against Matthews, ruling that he “cannot qualify as a major participant” in the Oct. 1, 2008, killing of Gonzales at the La Brea Collective and that “the evidence was insufficient as a matter of law to support the special circumstance, and Matthews is statutorily ineligible for life imprisonment without parole.”

In a 28-page ruling, Associate Justice Kathryn M. Werdegar wrote on behalf of the panel that “there was substantial evidence to show Matthews acted as the getaway driver for an armed robbery” and that jurors “could infer from Matthews’ movements that he dropped his confederates off near the dispensary” and then waited three blocks away for about 45 minutes.

“During the robbery and murder, Matthews was absent from the scene, sitting in a car and waiting. There was no evidence he saw or heard the shooting, that he could have seen or heard the shooting, or that he had any immediate role in instigating it or could have prevented it,” Werdegar wrote, with the other six justices concurring in the ruling.

“There was evidence from which the jury could infer Matthews knew he was participating in an armed robbery. But nothing at trial supported the conclusion beyond a reasonable doubt that Matthews knew his own actions would involve a grave risk of death,” the Supreme Court justices found in the ruling.

The California Supreme Court agreed to hear the case against Matthews to determine if the evidence was sufficient to show he was a “major participant” after a three-justice panel from California’s 2nd District Court of Appeal rejected the defense’s contention that Matthews did not know that co- defendants — Leon Banks, Brandon Daniels and David Gardiner — were going to commit a robbery.

The California Supreme Court refused to hear the case against Banks — the gunman — and Daniels, who was a “Los Angeles Top 10 Most Wanted” fugitive when he was arrested in 2010 in connection with Gonzales’ killing. Both men are serving life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Gardiner — who was arrested in July 2009 — pleaded no contest in April to first-degree murder and was sentenced to 45 years to life in state prison. He has not filed an appeal.

Related Posts

Actress Chanel Maya Banks Found in Texas, Family Disputes LAPD’s Closure of the Case

November 14, 2024

November 14, 2024

Family Questions Authenticity of Inflammatory Social Media Posts The events in the case of Chanel Maya Banks, the Playa Vista-based...

LA’s Food Access Farmers Markets Face Possible Closures, Call for Community Support

November 14, 2024

November 14, 2024

Nonprofit Seeks Monthly Donors To Continue to Offer Fresh Produce to the Underserved Food Access LA, the nonprofit organization behind...

SANTA MONICA HOTELS OFFER EXTRA BEDROOM PROGRAM FOR LOCALS WELCOMING VISITORS

November 13, 2024

November 13, 2024

SANTA MONICA, Calif. (November 11, 2024) – Santa Monica Travel & Tourism announces the return of the popular “I Wish...

(Video) What Parents Love about Vistamar’s Open House v1

November 13, 2024

November 13, 2024

Why attend a Vistamar admissions open house? Parents talk about all that you can experience when you visit. At Open...

Family Searches for Missing Actress Chanel Maya Banks; Asks For Public’s Help in West LA

November 13, 2024

November 13, 2024

Relatives Search for Chanel Maya Banks, Last Heard From on October 30 The family of an actress based on the...

Court Halts Order for Expedited Veteran Housing in West LA, Citing VA’s Budget Constraints

November 13, 2024

November 13, 2024

Former Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger Criticizes the VA on Veterans Day The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has temporarily paused an...

Armed Robbery in Culver City: Suspects Flee with $12,000 Rolex in Early Morning Incident

November 12, 2024

November 12, 2024

Two Suspects Targeted Man in Parking Lot, Brandishing Firearms, Demanding Valuables Culver City police are investigating an early morning armed...

Metro’s New Bus Lane Camera Enforcement Aims to Speed Up Commutes for LA Riders

November 12, 2024

November 12, 2024

Pilot Program Begins With 60-Day Warning Period to Clear Bus Lanes The Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority (Metro), in...

Legendary Actor Tony Todd, Known for Iconic Horror Roles, Dies at the Age of 69

November 12, 2024

November 12, 2024

Star of Candyman and Final Destination Remembered by Fans and Peers Iconic actor and Marina del Rey resident Tony Todd...

LAUSD Teacher Charged with Sexual Assault on a Minor, Police Believe There May Be Other Victims

November 11, 2024

November 11, 2024

Los Angeles County District Attorney George Gascón announced on November 8 that a middle school teacher, Colleen Jo Matarico, is...

Suspect Arrested, Another at Large After Culver City Vehicle Burglary

November 11, 2024

November 11, 2024

Police Ask Public for Assistance to Aid the Investigation Early morning on November 7, Culver City Police responded to reports...

Beverly Hills High Limits Student Gatherings After Pro-Trump Rally Disrupts Campus

November 11, 2024

November 11, 2024

Principal Cites Safety Concerns Following Post-Election Demonstration Beverly Hills High School has put limits on student gatherings after a pro-Trump...

LAX Runway Closures in November May Lead to Increased Aircraft Noise for Nearby Residents

November 10, 2024

November 10, 2024

Temporary Runway Shutdowns for Maintenance and Upgrades May Alter Flight Paths Los Angeles World Airports (LAWA) has announced temporary runway...

Racist Text Messages Target Students in Santa Monica, West LA, Raising Alarm Among Schools, Families

November 10, 2024

November 10, 2024

Outrage Spreads as Disturbing, Racially Charged Messages Reach Students and Others By Dolores Quintana Schools on the Westside of Los...

8 Things to Do in Big Bear Lake: A Local’s Guide to Adventure and Relaxation

November 8, 2024

November 8, 2024

Nestled in the San Bernardino Mountains, Big Bear Lake is a true gem for nature lovers, families, and adventurers alike....